« Due consigli (anzi, dieci !) per l'azienda 2.0 | Main | Chrome, browser e pubblicità online »

Quel brighella di Robin Goldstein

robin-goldstein-wine-spectator.jpg

Se ne è già parlato a sufficienza dello scandalino winespectator. Quel brighella di Robin Goldstein potrà forse appendere il cappello dopo questo botto che ha ormai fatto il giro del mondo. Vorrei solo provare a vedere la cosa anche da un'angolazione diversa. Se qualcuno mette in atto dei comportamenti e delle azioni volte ad indurti in errore attraverso artifici e raggiri, posto che non si tratta di truffa perché manca la parte relativa al "guadagno del truffatore" che - per ora - non si è attuata, è ben facile che tu, ingannato, cada nel tranello.

Alla luce di questo e soprattutto considerato il fatto che la competizione a quanto è dato apprendere dalla replica di WS è basata esclusivamente sulle carte dei vini, un pizzico di malizia nel gesto di Goldstein ce la si può anche vedere. A fin di bene, per carità. Giusto perché sono sempre stato uno a cui piace sentire le due campane, ecco la replica di Thomas Matthew, Executive Editor di Wine Spectator :


1. Wine Spectator's Restaurant Awards

Our Awards program was founded in 1981 to encourage restaurants to improve their wine programs, and to aid readers in finding restaurants that take wine seriously. The program evaluates the content, accuracy and presentation of restaurant wine lists. It does not purport to review the restaurant as a whole.

In the program's 27 years, we have evaluated more than 45,000 wine lists. There is no doubt that more restaurants offer good wine lists today than back in 1981. We would like to think that this program has contributed to that development. Further, our Dining Guide is a widely used resource by our subscribers. (View more information on the program here.)


2. How could a restaurant that doesn't exist earn an award for its wine list?

We do not claim to visit every restaurant in our Awards program. We do promise to evaluate their wine lists fairly. (Nearly one-third of new entries each year do not win awards.) We assume that if we receive a wine list, the restaurant that created it does in fact exist. In the application, the restaurant owner warrants that all statements and information provided are truthful and accurate. Of course, we make significant efforts to verify the facts.

In the case of Osteria L'Intrepido:

a. We called the restaurant multiple times; each time, we reached an answering machine and a message from a person purporting to be from the restaurant claiming that it was closed at the moment.

b. Googling the restaurant turned up an actual address and located it on a map of Milan

c. The restaurant sent us a link to a Web site that listed its menu

d. On the Web site Chowhound, diners (now apparently fictitious) discussed their experiences at the non-existent restaurant in entries dated January 2008, to August 2008.


3. How could this wine list earn an award?

On his blog, Goldstein posted a small selection of the wines on this list, along with their poor ratings from Wine Spectator. This was his effort to prove that the list - even if real - did not deserve an award.

However, this selection was not representative of the quality of the complete list that he submitted to our program. Goldstein posted reviews for 15 wines. But the submitted list contained a total of 256 wines. Only 15 wines scored below 80 points.

Fifty-three wines earned ratings of 90 points or higher (outstanding on Wine Spectator's 100-point scale) and a total of 102 earned ratings of 80 points (good) or better. (139 wines were not rated.) Overall, the wines came from many of Italy's top producers, in a clear, accurate presentation.

Here is our description of an Award of Excellence:
Our basic award, for lists that offer a well-chosen selection of quality producers, along with a thematic match to the menu in both price and style.

The list from L'Intrepido clearly falls within these parameters.


4. What did Goldstein achieve?

It has now been demonstrated that an elaborate hoax can deceive Wine Spectator.

This act of malicious duplicity reminds us that no one is completely immune to fraud. It is sad that an unscrupulous person can attack a publication that has earned its reputation for integrity over the past 32 years. Wine Spectator will clearly have to be more vigilant in the future.

Most importantly, however, this scam does not tarnish the legitimate accomplishments of the thousands of real restaurants who currently hold Wine Spectator awards, a result of their skill, hard work and passion for wine."


[Foto credit : Thewinetrials.com]

Commenti

During the premier week Big sibling divided the HouseGuests into four sets of three; Athletes, Populars, Brains, and Off-beats. A thirteenth HouseGuest begined to afford one set an drop closed the others.[4] Four HouseGuests from over and done with seasons returned to reinforcement one of each sets. Michael "Cowboy" Ellis of Big sibling 5 reinforcemented the Off-beats, Jessica Hughbanks of Big sibling 8 back uped the Populars, Brian Hart of Big sibling 10 back uped the Brains, and Jessie Godderz also from Big fellow 10 reinforcemented the Athletes. The set that won the start with crisis of Household, the Athletes, won Jessie Godderz to go the line and develop [url=http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/member.php?u=51048]big brother 11[/url] shard of their set. He also became the ahead prime minister of Household of the season.

[b]Diamond Studs[/b]

Selection of over 400 [url=http://www.simplydiamondstuds.com]diamond studs[/url] earring sizes and qualities delivered
overnight. Certified diamond quality. What could be more elegant and easier
to wear than diamond studs? You can wear them every day or save them for
special occasions. Of course, if you wear studs every day, you probably
want another pair of diamond earrings for those big events. We feature a
vast array of styles. Studs with round diamonds are the most classic;
square-shaped princess diamonds or yellow diamonds are a contemporary
alternative. Our elegant stud earrings feature .25 carat total weight of
round brilliant diamonds, independantly certified to be I2-I3 clarity, J-M
color and Fair Cut.

Visit: http://www.simplydiamondstuds.com

[b]Best Eye Cream[/b]

Are you looking for the absolute [url=http://www.besteyecreamreview.com/]best eye cream[/url]? Then you have come to right place. My wife and I have extensively tested many eye creams until we finally found one that worked GREAT! If you are sick of wasting money and want the absolute best eye cream then look on further. Right now Ageless is offering a free trial, hurry before it ends!

Visit: http://www.besteyecreamreview.com/

[b]Annonces gratuites[/b]

"Retrouvez sur ce site les petites annonces gratuites animaux, les annonces gratuites auto et annonces moto. PasseTonAnnonce c'est aussi des milliers de petites annonces immobilier pour trouver un appartement a louer facilement ! Toutes ces [url=http://www.topdil.fr]annonces gratuites[/url] sont publiées imméditament parmis des milliers de petites annonces gratuites classées. "

[url=http://www.topdil.fr]Petites Annonces gratuites[/url], [url=http://www.topdil.fr]Petites annonces[/url]

http://www.topdil.fr

very useful post. I would love to follow you on twitter. By the way, did any one know that some Iranian hacker had hacked twitter yesterday.

happy not money, and how their leverage http://www.pimp-my-profile.com/users/cliphunter ">3dl If you can't stand the heat , get out of the kitcen http://www.pimp-my-profile.com/users/dogspics ">flowingwoo

I am impressed! I look at many blogs every day, and I must say that yours is number one. Please do continue, I do not want you to stop. Yours Sincerely ... Flora Sucharski

Allr right-thinking teen ager know that evironazis are running terrible because Britain is now under shraia law.T he silent majority must use napalm.

Might it be possible that you might show us all how exactly they manage to make posts of such high caliber? Heck, even the title TigullioVino.it Weblog Network: Quel brighella di Robin Goldstein stirs me profoundly.

I switched specialists mainly because after a few years with Intense pulsed light, I realized the results were not worth it. Then I got the tria hair removal. They warranty that after 2 yrs if hair grows back, the treatments are actually free of charge. They have both laserlight and also Ipl, but I am going to stay with laser now being Ipl did not seem to decrease the quantity of hair returning.

I've performed intensive two-week golf schools too as five-minute lessons. I’ve taught corporate CEOs and manual laborers.

They are saying, you must love money and have a passion for simple mathematics for profitable lottery. I do! ))Next, you need to to review the percentages of winning. My question is how? Any suggestions are appreciated?

Exceptional write-up, keep the fantastic work. I'm a visiting tutor at Goldsmiths University, London, and am around the editorial board of an online discussion board for sector pros. You gave me some fantastic ideas for my own internet site.

Interesting article and one which should be more widely known about in my view. Your level of detail is good and the clarity of writing is excellent. I have bookmarked it for you so that others will be able to see what you have to say.

Interesting article and one which should be more widely known about in my view. Your level of detail is good and the clarity of writing is excellent. I have bookmarked it for you so that others will be able to see what you have to say.

Interesting article and one which should be more widely known about in my view. Your level of detail is good and the clarity of writing is excellent. I have bookmarked it for you so that others will be able to see what you have to say.

Interesting article and one which should be more widely known about in my view. Your level of detail is good and the clarity of writing is excellent. I have bookmarked it for you so that others will be able to see what you have to say.

inordinate entry you've occupy

I’d have to settle with you here. Which is not something I usually do! I love reading a post that will make people think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment!

Due to various reasons that are tied to a certain place, a video game, already released in some places and that looks absolutely acceptable in one place can be criticized as the devil incarnate once released in a new territory. This is a good reason to thin that video game adaptation - unlike translation- is a must for video games.

However I've often been wondering: when does the "localization" of content stop being "localization" and turn into full-on "censorship"? Aren't these changes killing some of the game's fun?

I will show you a simple example, Yakuza 3 on PS3 shows well how thin the frontier between censorship and localization can be. The game was heavily criticized by gamers who suspect the localizerd edited or removed significant game elements.

This gets me wondering: how much of the cut content was actually "inappropriate for American audiences" as in "cultural differences would prevent full understanding and therefore only serve to confuse the player and impede their progress", as opposed to "Americans are generally far more religious and uptight than Japanese people, so we can't show them this kind of nudity and/or violence"? Gamers were most likely expecting something different after reading about the game in specialized media

Most of gamers are reasonable adults who just want to enjoy the game as it is, instead of playing an edited, censored version of it. So please, developers, think of gamers first when you are localizing your games.

Video game localization should be given more consideration, and before censoring, developers should rather listen to their gamers at first.

That could be worse but demographically speaking, this is the case.

Hi man did you had new links ? I care clerical improve so me ... ..

I wouldn’t think I have ever noticed a blog site with this many comments on there!

Sometimes I just think that people write and dont really have much to say. Not so here

I attempted to post a comment before, but it hasn’t shown up. I feel the spam filtering could be broken?

Hair Getting regular trims is essential. Using a smoothing serum that works for your hair can do wonders to make your hair shiny and beautiful in a flash. Combined with a ceramic flat iron, your hair will look shiny and silky smooth in minutes, even if you didn't eat right or get enough sleep

I have to admit that i sometimes get bored to read the whole thing but i think that your blog can be an exception. Cheers !

I attempted to post a statement previously, but it hasn’t shown up. I think the spam filtering could be broken

I tried to post a comment previously, but it hasn’t shown up. I think the spam filter may be broken

I attempted to post a statement earlier, however it hasn’t shown up. I feel your spam filtering could be broken

...well okay so that's the perspective here

Well written and interesting. Congrats!

I tried to submit a comment previously, but it hasn’t shown up. I believe your spam filtering may possibly be defective

Hey, I'd like to buy advertising space on your site. If you contact me, we'll work something out... You can email me or contact me through my site (I left it as my name). Let me know as soon as possible please.

thanks, nice one but when is the next post coming around? When I check the dates it it like you do not post too often!??!

I wouldn’t think I have ever noticed a blog site with this many comments on there!

hitch rack ski trailer

very good \o/

Interesting , how would I make use of this?

Hot topic, people are starting to worry more about preparing for what they would do if their vehicle stops working. Tune in to Lifetime Channels The Balancing Act in Dec., they are going to have a spokesman from a big vehicle extended coverage brokerage on to explain what a vehicle service contract is and what the best coverage is for your vehicle.

Oh boy! It's like you understand my mind! You seem to know a lot about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you can do with some images to drive the content home a bit, but other than that, this is great blog. A wonderful read. I'll definitely be back.

The first three beliefs that top my list are there for that reason, pure and simple.

Thank you so much for this! I have not been this moved by a blog post for a long period of time! You have got it, whatever that means in blogging. Well, You are definitely somebody that has something to say that people need to hear. Keep up the good work. Keep on inspiring the people!

I'd debate you on the post, but you'd win. It’s not the size of the dog in the fight, it’s the size of the fight in the dog.

This was refreshing. I wished I could read every post, but i have to go back to work now... But I'll return.

Thanks for this post. I definitely agree with what you are saying. I have been talking about this subject a lot lately with my father so hopefully this will get him to see my point of view. Fingers crossed!

Greetings to all, This webpage is good and so is the way the theme was written about. I like some of the comments as well even though I would rather we focus on the topic in order add value to the idea. It will be also encouraging to the writer if we all could make mention of it (for some of you who use bookmarking services such as a delicious, facebook,..). Thanks again.

This webpage has so much good information on it, I check on it every few hours. I wish other sites spent as much effort as this one does making information "to the point" to readers like myself. I recommend this page to all of my facebook friends. This page will make some massive passive profit I'm certain.

It is not long ago when I discussed that topic with just the same outcome.

It appears that you have put a good amount of effort into your blog and this world require more of these on the Internet these days. The both of us actually enjoyed your post. I do not have a great deal to say in reply, I just wanted to sign up to reply well done.I always learn something new from your post!

Could you message me with any hints & tips about how you made this blog look this awesome, I'd be thankful.

Thanks for this post. I definitely agree with what you are saying. I have been talking about this subject a lot lately with my father so hopefully this will get him to see my point of view. Fingers crossed!

I wouldn’t think I have ever noticed a blog site with this many comments on there!

Ein Anleger zu seinem Berater: "ist tatsächlich mein ganzes Geld weg?" Der Berater antwortet: "nein, natürlich nicht. Es gehört eben nur einem anderen!"

I'm getting a browser error, is anyone else?

"I pull you from your tower, take away your pain. Show you all the beauty you possess, if you only let yourself believe." ~ Sarah McLachlan

"The most beautiful things in the world cannot be seen or even touched, they must be felt with the heart." ~ Helen Keller

Samp. Fear me not.

"The realization that we are all basically the same human beings who seek happiness and try to avoid suffering is very helpful in developing a sense of brotherhood and sisterhood; a warm feeling of love and compassion for others."

I'm a ginormous kpop fan! lol Love SNSD forever! Seeyas xoxo

I wouldn’t think I have ever noticed a blog site with this many comments on there!

You probably have seen the a special system that will people become taller or possibly a workout to elevate levels.

An uncaring person would not have a concern touching on.

Reminds me of:I got the bill for my surgery. Now I know what those doctors were wearing masks for. ~James H. Boren

yr 7: "miss Turner, do you like Goldielocks? i wish she was my wife" ...i always enjoy teaching the special class

Samp. [aside to Gregory] Is the law of our side if I say ay?

How come that below age young children from India travel alone to Europe and get missing? Every yr there arrive all around a 100 underage Indian Boys for the Netherlands. They travel without having family or other guard. After they arrive they ask for migration. The authorities give them housing with extra surveillance. Right after a view weeks, from time to time hrs the boys get missing. The authorities is unable to get them. In 5 years greater than 500 underneath age boy are reported as missing and only a couple are found back again. So I'm questioning what took place to individuals boys in India and inside Netherlands?

I just stopped by to say Merry Christmas. Wish you all a better year

Wishing you a merry Christmas and a fantastic holiday season, and here's to a prosperous New Year too!

This was refreshing. I wished I could read every post, but i have to go back to work now... But I'll be back.

I liked a lot from them in the field, thanks to authors and administrators.

I don't even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was interesting. Cheers!

Not to say that directors can't make great films when they're young, or in middle age, about a man in the dark days of the golden years (About Schmidt, Tokyo Story, Bob Le Flambeur, and Kurosawa's own Ikiru come to mind).

That thoughts reminds me personally in which now could possibly your suitable chance to more one’s college education and learning. WE speculate whether or not WE may require instruction on the web. Presently there appear to be a ton of scholarship chances these days which were as soon as so pretty obscure to get a very few in years past.

Hey I'm from germany and would like to use some of your article on my blog would that be okay?

I saw something about this subject on TV last night. Good post.

A successful man is one who can lay a firm foundation with the bricks others have thrown at him. – David Brinkley. Great blog you have here !

Very happy to relate that i found your blog posts of great help to me. I often seek out this collection of material and it was a treat to discover such a good level of information

Great blog man, had very important content that I can relate to :)

Unfortunately I can't really get in same terms as you are right now lol. But I supposed you're just giving your opinion so I'm giving mine.. Your post just didn't sound too right to me haha.

I dont quite agree with what you're trying to say.. Is this even worth arguing about? It's quite pointless.. But it is your opinion so I still respect it somewhat lols

I'd have to disagree with your opinions on this one haha. What is the point you're trying to make? Seems like you're just talking without knowing anything.. no offense :x

Totally agreeing with your opinion right now! I feel as if what you are saying is very true ^^ Quite sad not everybody knows about this but I'm sure sooner or later they'll find out keke.

Honestly, I liked what you write about a lot haha, really makes sense and it's something I can apply my life too. I'm very glad that someone else feels the same way.. Hard to find people like this haha

Honestly, I liked what you write about a lot haha, really makes sense and it's something I can apply my life too. Quite sad not everybody knows about this but I'm sure sooner or later they'll find out keke.

Honestly, I liked what you write about a lot haha, really makes sense and it's something I can apply my life too. Hopefully everyone starts realizing about it and begin living it!

Was you grow up, she will have no option than to loosen up those strings as she wholly gives herself to you.

Come over to Australia to see how things are done and how everyone lives in harmony. Once you have been here you will love it and not want to go back. Quality of life is so much better here. South Africa has failed already but sadly most South African wont admit to the crime and corruption. They are immune to it already. If you love South Africa more than your familys welfare stay there enjoy it while it lasts

I honestly did not think this issue that way. I assume that there's a point in all of this. Delighted to be able to participate. Wish you good luck.

I actually undoubtedly have to think more in that direction and find out things i can do about that.

When I open up your Rss feed it appears to be a lot of nonsense, is the issue on my part?

Hm, Now i am comfortable with this however not utterly confident, hence i'm going to research a touch more.

Reminds me of:It is a mathematical fact that fifty percent of all doctors graduate in the bottom half of their class. ~Author Unknown

thanks, I'll add this blog to my favourites

I think this fits your post: It is sometimes as dangerous to be run into by a microbe as by a trolley car. ~J.J. Walsh

Came into my mind when reading: A doctor who cannot take a good history and a patient who cannot give one are in danger of giving and receiving bad treatment. ~Author Unknown

Hey peeps, would you please weed out some of the advertising so it's cleaner to enjoy your posts? I am on a glacial connection and it is almost impossible to read your comments!

This was refreshing. I wished I could read every post, but i have to go back to work now... But I'll return.

This was refreshing. I wished I could read every post, but i have to go back to work now... But I'll return.

This was refreshing. I wished I could analyze every post, but i have to go back to work now... But I'll return.

I get cranky when I see so many comments on blogs that are just generic and have no relation to what the blogger originally wrote about.

Hello My name is Halssabspedge and I'm really interested how interesting this forum is . So, I onlywant to know : how long should i wait before I'll get an answer to my questions.
Thanks

great stuf, i love it

I hate seeing all these generic spammy comments on good blogs like this one. It's such a waste of space.

Because I'm a pagan, Pujols batting .500 from now till early October guarantees him a pass. In my dictionary this is the definition of “American Exceptionalism.” La Russa, on the other hand, falls into the “other” category, and is a candidate for Brother Dobson's biting metal-strapped girdle.

Good post, read and seen many of his mistakes, but did not see the main:)

Its also worth noting that everyone named in the Mitchell Report has been let off the hook, but the legal harassment of Bonds continues. Theres still a very good chance that Barry will be exonerated of perjury charges, and that Clemens will be convicted that must keep Selig awake and sweating. It wouldnt surprise me if Selig is hoping just the opposite, and has convinced the owners to lay off Bonds till his case has gone to court, figuring that by then, however it turns out, hell have been out of the game long enough that hell just retire.

Hello everybody, how do you do
My name's Pigeon Johnny
LA symph's the band
I know what you're point of view
Who is this deceive
My prestige's Pigeon Johnny
I prepare the ladies drool
Not as a matter of fact but it sounds self-control allowing

I do not even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was good. I don't know who you are but definitely you are going to a famous blogger if you are not already ;) Cheers!

It seems like no one even takes the time to read the original blog post before posting a comment. Very lazy, people.

You make some excellent points. How do you create ideas? Sometimes I find myself like I am running out of good material to examine and share with my readers.. I honestly never thought of this before you shared. Keep posting man. I seriously enjoy reading your thoughts because in turn they give me - (and I'm sure your other readers) much to take into consideration.

Knowledgable post.It's fantastic that someone can communicate so well. In my judgement, communication with this topic hasn't exactly been the best. I found you on Alta Vista.

I read your orientation frequently and I well-deserved rationality I'd hint jail up the salubrious creation!

Eine Kollegin scherzte und meinte, dass sie trotzdem auch mal gerne mit ihm duschen gehen würde.

Hate to break it to you but I keep getting a 503 error when I try to post a comment. I don't even know why I am trying again but just in case you notice...

Thanks relating to the post, it's good to hear another person's opinion. I surely agree with exactly what you are saying in regards to the information in a very completely different manner to assist make new connections. Please sustain the nice work as I'm definitely going again to read more.

Posta un tuo commento

TigullioVino.it - Cultura del Vino & Comunicazione
Web : www.tigulliovino.it
E-mail : info@tigulliovino.it